Mixed signals
These days, actresses are too thin. This just in from Captain Obvious.
OK, so it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to gather the empirical evidence (Kiera, more than one Kate, Angelina, more than one Nicole — and now even the previously bodacious Kristen Johnston is looking rexi).
The media at large and Hollywood make their bread and butter (ahem) in part by (overtly or not) encouraging actresses and models to “diet” themselves to the verge of malnutrition (how many jobs would Kiera get if her spare frame added 30 lbs? How many covers of top magazines would Nicole Ritchie — whose resume is as thin as her post-partum wasp waist — appear on?) and cashing in on the lucrative advertising, movie, god help us singing and modeling gigs they generate. Not to mention the controversy and increased exposure (and bigger, juicier paychecks) their increasingly wraith-like jutaciousness.
Living in a society where starvation is an issue for very few of its inhabitants, where walking down any city street you’re bombarded with images of bony divas juxtaposed with ads for 700 calorie coffee drinks and muffins could only lead to a justifiably addled perspective on food consumption. So you’ve got your average obese American who hates him/herself (my lanky, hot husband who is the last person who I would expect to fall victim to body dysmorphic disorder just last night referred to himself as a willowy marshmellow when I asked why he was comparing the pros of various local gyms), your American who’s perfectly svelte but lives in fear of becoming obese and obsesses over every last calorie and the miraculous few who are too smart, clueless or genetically blessed to give their love handles a second thought.
I do know that our coverage of dangerously thin models and actresses has to change. I love New York magazine — it’s witty, smart, cool but not overly so — and I rarely disagree with its tone. But a recent review of Get Smart struck me as oddly offensive precisely for those reasons.
Here’s a snippet:
“Like most young actresses, [Anne] Hathaway has dropped too many pounds — in a couple of shots her cheeks have sunken so deep that they can barely hold her giant teeth. But the sleekness, hard lines, the blacks and bright green against that ivory skin — yowza. I also like the scene where she wears a tousled jacket and loosened tie: It says ‘Okay, boys. Deal me in.’ After this and The Devil Wears Prada, Hathaway must have designers camping out in front of her co-op.”
Let me get this straight: Hathaway is so skinny, all of the lovely, womanly fat on her face has completely disappeared; in fact, she looks like a horse when she smiles — her scrawny cheeks can “barely hold her giant teeth.” “Yowza.” I don’t know how David Edelstein got from point A to point B, and I’m not even going to address the “Okay boys. Deal me in” bit.
Just out of curiousity, after reading the piece I googled actresses anorexic. I got 459,000 hits. actresses too thin. I got 303,000 hits. actresses skinny beautiful. I got 1,060,000 hits. Boo.
Today, news of a model killing herself was reported — she may have had emotional problems. Surprise.
Fox News showed footage of her shattered body post-jump.




